Bigfoot in Fayette County: Haunting Legends & Trailside Stories Near Benner’s Meadow Run

Into the Woods: Is Bigfoot Real?

Ever heard something rustling in the woods and wondered, wait, was that Bigfoot? If you're staying at Benner’s Meadow Run, you're in one of the most legendary regions for Bigfoot sightings in Pennsylvania. The Laurel Highlands, including Fayette County and nearby Ohiopyle State Park, are packed with deep forests, quiet hollows, and just enough mystery to make you glance over your shoulder. For years, locals and curious campers alike have reported strange sightings out here, including “big, shadowy figures” that vanish just as quickly as they appear. Could it be Bigfoot? Well, that’s for you to decide!

Why Here? Fayette County Is Prime Bigfoot country

According to the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization (yep, that’s a real thing), Pennsylvania consistently ranks among the top 10 states for Bigfoot sightings, with over 130 documented reports — including five “Class A” (aka: most credible) encounters right here in Fayette County. That means people have had some pretty wild experiences that couldn’t easily be explained away.

With thick woods, shadowy hollows, and almost no light pollution, this area (especially around Chestnut Ridge) is prime Squatch country!  It’s no surprise that some campers at Benner’s love turning a hike into a bit of a Bigfoot hunt. Around here, the rolling hills and deep forests have earned the nickname “Pennsylvania’s Twilight Zone”, where spooky stories and strange sightings are all part of the fun!

Famous Sightings: Bigfoot’s Fayette County Footprints

Let's look at five particularly eerie encounters that are just minutes from Benner’s Meadow Run:

1. Dawson, PA — August 1974
   Two boys came face-to-face with an ~8-foot tall, hairy being in thick brambles. The creature stared at them before disappearing into the forest.
2. Near Uniontown / Zaleski Forest – July 1975
   Late at night, a witness saw two glowing red eyes  in the underbrush and heard heavy breathing before the creature vanished. By morning, the area was heavily trampled. It’s one of the region’s classic—and creepiest—Bigfoot stories.
3. Near Connellsville, PA — October 1994
   A 13-year-old boy and his siblings came across a gorilla-like figure near some dirt hills. It didn’t strut like a bear, and it left a lasting impression on their minds.
4. Breakneck Road near Connellsville, PA — July 1997
   While riding ATVs, two cousins saw a tall, brown, hairy creature sprint across a forest path—using two legs only. It seemed too fast and upright to be a bear.
5. Near Masontown, PA— September 1999
   A motorist saw an 8-foot tall figure with red eyes and brown hair standing upright. It screamed and ran off into the woods.

Fact, Fiction, or Campfire Tale?

Modern-day sightings sometimes pop up in news articles—for instance, a National Weather Service photographer snapped a storm-damage image in Fayette County that appeared to capture a large ape-like silhouette in the background. Locals quickly pointed out that clever residents sometimes place Bigfoot statues in their yards—just to mess with tourists.

Despite decades of sightings, no hard scientific evidence confirms the existence of Bigfoot. Skeptics point to mistaking black bears walking upright, pranks, or optical illusions in the forest. Still, the mystery lives on—and it’s part of the charm.

Bigfoot Meets Campground: Legends Come Alive After Sundown

Here’s how the Sasquatch lore becomes part of your stay at Benner’s:

• Scenic Trails & Mystery Walks: Trails like Sugarloaf and Quebec Run are dense and atmospheric.  Ideal spots for a “maybe-Bigfoot” sighting.
  Bigfoot Scavenger Hunts: Create fun hunts for kids like footprint markers, odd branch structures, and hidden items make for an adventurous legend-inspired game.
• Campfire Story Nights: Kick back by the fire and trade creepy local legends, Bigfoot sightings, and campfire tales that’ll give you just the right amount of goosebumps (and something to listen and look for when walking at night!)
• Local Bigfoot Events: Don’t miss the annual PA Bigfoot Camping Adventure held right here at Benner’s! This fun-filled weekend features top Bigfoot researchers and TV personalities, hands-on workshops, guided night hikes, family-friendly activities, and plenty of Bigfoot merch to take home.

Tips for Your Own Bigfoot Adventure

• Hike Dawn or Dusk: Most sightings happen at those twilight hours, when wildlife is active and it’s eerily peaceful.
• Pack Light but Smart: Bring binoculars, headlamps, a camera, comfy boots, and maybe marshmallows for a campfire toast!  If you’re a pro, bring your Bigfoot stick to summon the local legend…
• Stick to Scenic Trails: Head to Sugarloaf or Jonathan Run for thick woods, subtle streams, and forest whispers.
• Watch for Clues: Look for large footprints (some over 13"), or odd smells or wood knocks bark formations.
• Leave No Trace – The forest is best preserved, and respected, when visitors tread lightly.
• Record What You See – Write notes or snap a photo if you notice something mysterious in the woods.

Sample Bigfoot & Camp Itinerary at Benner’s

• Evening Day 1: Arrive at Benner’s, set up camp, and trade Bigfoot tales around the fire…
• Morning Day 2: Hike Breakneck or Sugarloaf. Look for tracks and listen for unexplained sounds.
• Afternoon Day 2: Shuttle to the GAP in Connellsville and do some biking. Then, take a scenic visit to Ohiopyle State Park.
• Evening Day 2: Tell “creepy forest tales” by firelight. Kid-friendly Bigfoot bingo cards! Always take a stroll in the dark but make sure that you have GPS and your bearings.
• Morning Day 3: Quiet morning walk at Quebec Run. Capture forest photos and maybe some hurtling red eyes?‍
  

‍

Whether or not Bigfoot is actually lurking in the Laurel Highlands, the mystery sure makes your camping trip a whole lot more exciting. There’s just something about hiking a trail where someone swears they saw a towering, hairy creature vanish into the trees, am I right? Even if it turns out to be a deer, or your buddy playing a prank, it’s all part of the story…

Here at Benner’s, we LOVE a good mystery and time well spent in the outdoors. So pack your sense of wonder, your camera (just in case), and your best Bigfoot call (they sell em at the festival). Whether you leave as a true believer or just with a spooky story to share back at the fire pit, exploring Bigfoot country near Ohiopyle is a blast.

Happy squatching and enjoying every wild moment out in the woods. Who knows… maybe you’ll spot something big, hairy, and walking on two legs!